While many employees have returned to the office full time, some employees are still able to work primarily from home. If that’s your arrangement then you may be able to claim home-office expenses when you file your tax return. But, if you do claim, pay careful attention to the rules, or the Canada Revenue Agency could challenge your claim, as one taxpayer recently experienced in a case decided earlier this month.
Before delving into the details of this recent case, let’s review the rules. The CRA’s position is that you can write off your home-office expenses if your home workspace is where you “principally” — meaning more than 50 per cent of the time — performed your duties of employment for a period of at least four consecutive weeks during the year.
For example, if you’re in a hybrid work arrangement where you go into the office on Tuesdays and Wednesdays (or 40 per cent of the time), this condition would be satisfied since you are working from home the other three out of five weekdays (60 per cent).
To be able to make a claim, you’ll need to get a signed copy of CRA form T2200- Declaration of Conditions of Employment from your employer. The T2200 is not submitted with your return, but you’re required to keep it in case the CRA asks to see it later.
You can claim a variety of home-office expenses, such as the cost of rent, utilities, maintenance and minor repair costs, and home internet access fees. You generally can’t deduct mortgage interest, property taxes, home insurance, capital expenses (such as changing a furnace or windows) or depreciation (capital cost allowance).
Commission-based employees who sell goods or negotiate contracts can claim some expenses that salaried employees cannot, specifically: home insurance; property taxes and the costs to lease a cellphone and devices such as a computer, laptop or tablet that relate to earning commission income.
For utilities, rent and other home expenses you need to allocate the expenses on a “reasonable basis” to determine the portion related to employment use. This is typically done by dividing the area of the workspace by the total finished area of the home, including hallways, bathrooms, kitchens and so on.
The recent tax case involved an Edmonton taxpayer who, in November 2020, took a permanent full-time position as an executive director with Saskatchewan’s Ministry of Finance. She moved to Regina and rented an apartment there.
Unfortunately, the taxpayer’s job was short-lived as she was terminated by her employer in May 2021. She sued her former employer, resulting in a lump-sum settlement payment in 2022.
The taxpayer’s one-year lease for her Regina apartment ended in October 2021 but she continued to lease it on a month-to-month basis until March 2022 when she left. Throughout this time she also kept her residence in Edmonton.
After she lost her job she didn’t work for the rest of 2021 or 2022. When she filed her 2021 and 2022 tax returns she claimed various employment deductions, including legal fees to negotiate her severance pay, home office expenses and supplies.
The CRA allowed the taxpayer’s legal fees, as well as part of her 2021 home office expenses, but disallowed any deductions related to the period after May 2021 and for all of 2022 on the basis that the taxpayer was no longer employed after her termination.
For the period until May 31, 2021, the CRA also challenged how much space the taxpayer was using for work and thus what percentage of the taxpayer’s rent, heat, insurance and internet for her Regina apartment should be deductible.
The taxpayer introduced as evidence a floor plan for the apartment and estimated that it measured about 558 square feet. The taxpayer testified that the bedroom she used when residing at the apartment was about 107 square feet and comprised 19.2 per cent of her personal space. She set up her office in the second bedroom, which measured about 83 square feet or 14.9 per cent of the total space. The rest of the apartment comprised a kitchen area, dining area, living room and a bathroom.
The taxpayer’s position is that she used 50 per cent, if not more, of the space in her apartment for work until her employment was terminated. The CRA disagreed and concluded that the taxpayer only used 37 per cent of the apartment space for employment purposes, and therefore allowed only 37 per cent of her total home office expenses for a total $3,102 (being total expenses of $8,383 x 37 per cent).
After reviewing the testimony, the judge concluded that the taxpayer used one bedroom in the apartment as an office and may have sometimes used the dining and living room areas for work or an occasional meeting during the COVID pandemic. As a result, he felt that the 37 per cent allowed by the CRA for the months of January through to May 2021 was generous, as it “likely exceeds the actual use considering the taxpayer needed a place to reside in Regina and the smaller bedroom which she used as an office represented about 14.9 per cent of the space.”
The taxpayer also tried to deduct home office expenses for amounts she incurred after her employment was terminated, for the balance of 2021 and into 2022. She testified that she needed, and used, the apartment so that she could be available to work with her litigation counsel in Regina.
While that may be true, noted the judge, it did not follow that her post-employment home office expenses could be deducted for the period after May 2021 when she had been terminated.
The CRA also allowed the taxpayer to deduct amounts she paid in the period January to May 2021 for her cellphone ($289.13), but only allowed office supplies of $178.19, versus the $751.12 the taxpayer had claimed on her return. To support the higher claim, the taxpayer brought into court “a large bundle of documents that included receipts,” but failed to give evidence about what was purchased, claiming that the information was already provided to the CRA.
The judge wasn’t amused, saying “this Court is not a speedy drop box for bundles of receipts. In the absence of an agreement about the facts, (a taxpayer) should expect to provide testimony about the items purchased.”
Among the items claimed, and rejected by the CRA, were: a lamp; a red folding side-table and a red Adirondack chair bought in Edmonton towards the end of May 2021.
The judge refused to allow any of these “office supplies” beyond the $178 previously allowed by the CRA.